Online ordering powered by Seamless
525 Grand St. (Grand St. Between Henry St. & Broadway)(212) 477-3367
Minimum order of $12.00 is required for delivery
+ $1.00 delivery fee (more info)
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $12.00 is required for delivery
+ $1.00 delivery fee (more info)
Delivery estimate is 55 - 70 min (more info)
Print this menu
Served with your choice of pasta or salad.
Please No Special Instructions. Request may NOT be honored or considered. Items are as stated in menu.
Served with small salad and can of soda.
Served on Italian bread.
No substitutions. Served with a small minestrone soup or salad.
Our Pizza is now served Brick Oven Style!
Available daily until 7 PM (unless stated otherwise). Our Pizza is now served Brick Oven Style!
All sandwiches served on Italian bread.
Served with choice of salad or pasta.
Flash frozen to ensure freshness. If you'd like this thawed out, please request in special instructions.
This family owned pizzeria restaurant was founded over 68 years ago. Pizza Shack’s menu features classic Italian dishes, traditional fare and assorted specialties that have been favorites of Italian cuisine lovers all over the world. Each item has been selected from a long list of traditional Italian family recipes and is prepared to order using only the freshest ingredients available. If they have missed one of your daily specials, they would be pleased to make your favorite dish even if it’s not the menu. So give Pizza Shack a try. Remember, they’re pizza, pasta and more, and will deliver it fresh and fast to your door!
Bruschetta alla Pomodoro—Toasted bread topped with fresh tomatoes and olive oil broiled to perfection
Pizza Shack Salad—Romaine lettuce tossed with tomatoes, onions and cucumbers
Manicotti and Cheese—Stuffed pasta tubes with creamy Ricotta cheese and herbs
Chicken Pizzaiola—Chicken with green peppers, onions and mushrooms in a light Marinara sauce
Pizza Shack House Pizza—Spinach, mushrooms, broccoli, sausage, pepperoni, green peppers and onions
Chicken Marsala Pizza—Chicken with Marsala wine sauce and mushrooms
Pizza Shack is also available to cater your next party or corporate event.
The time to deliver is well over an hour. Still waiting for my food, which apparently left 40 minutes ago. Can't wait to have a cold dinner
Posted 2 years ago by Robyn K.
Horrible customer service. Never get delivery again!!!
Posted 2 years ago by Kerri H.
Quick delivery, ok food....worth trying
Posted 2 years ago by Freddie D.
Solid. Quick, usually very good. A staple in my repertoire.
Posted 2 years ago by Mike D.
One of my favorite two pizza joints in the LES area.
Posted 2 years ago by Chi Y.
best pizza in the area! i love this place. my favorites: house special pie (everything), eggplant parm, meatball parm, spinach salad with white bean. i've been a happy customer for the last 10 years. try their italian specialties- not just the pizza. there's a reason this place has been around since the Reagan years.
Posted 2 years ago by John B.
Great food, friendly and prompt delivery, and when there was a mistake made on their part, they took care of it with no issue. Overall awesome place!
Posted 2 years ago by Alex L.
Excellent service, excellent pizza. The sicilian is the best!
Posted 2 years ago by Anthony M.
Ordered the Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero, was delicious! Fast Delivery.
Posted 2 years ago by Tony M.
Vodka pizza and Sicilian pizza delicious!!!
Posted 2 years ago by Michelle K.
I can't stop eating this pizza...it is amazing!!
Posted 2 years ago by Mary P.
Best lasagna I've had in New York, seriously. Also delicious pizza. I was really surprised that a place with a name like "Pizza Shack" would be that good.
Posted 2 years ago by Soleil K.
The food is good
Posted 2 years ago by Carmen s.
this place was wonderful. the pizza was excellent. the pasta was great. they followed my instructions perfectly. the delivery came on time. the delivery person was very courteous. good job!
Posted 2 years ago by alphonse d.
Very good pasta and calamari.
Posted 2 years ago by brenda l.
Pizza shack has awesome food the pizzas are superb besides the salads are fresh and delicious dressing. By far the best pizza/Italian place in Lower East Side!!!
Posted 2 years ago by Claris G.
Took an hour to receive the pizza; pizza was alright but nothing special.
Posted 2 years ago by Todd S.
Pizza is just okay, but +1 for delivering in a snow storm.
Posted 2 years ago by Joe B.
This food is amazing!!!!!
Posted 2 years ago by Jonathan S.
I live around the corner from this place and delivery took over an hour. Cold pizza that was gross.
Posted 2 years ago by Alana B.
the worst looking and tasting pizza i've ever seen or eaten.
Posted 2 years ago by Luke S.
I love this place. They are polite when you call and their food is never disappointing. Delivery is always fast and the food is always hot. Definitely a great place to order from, especially if you're looking for great pasta.
Posted 2 years ago by Tiffanie G.
If you have literally hours to wait for delivery .....the food is just ok. I've been living in a co op here for years and can't deal with the slow service
Posted 2 years ago by Angela N.
Food took two hours to eventually get here. Called the restaurant after an hour they said the guy was on his way. The guy finally came to my building, doorman called me to let him up, but he never showed up at my door. I called the place, they said he got in an accident on the way, but if that's the case why did my doorman call me to say my food was here. They said give us 15 minutes and we'll send a new order over. 30 minutes later they say the guy is on the way give us 5 minutes. Another 30 minutes go buy and the new guy finally shows up.
The whole situation is clouded in mystery and poor service. I don't understand any of it. BTW, the food was below average, and they got the order wrong.
Posted 2 years ago by Nicholaus T.
very delayed delivery and dismissive when I called to check the status.
Posted 2 years ago by David B.
Solid pizza. Flavor packets are a nice touch. French fries were soggy, but edible. 40 min. delivery.
Posted 2 years ago by Anne M.
Horrible. Sauce is super sweat not my style. Soup had no taste. Not recommending.
Posted 2 years ago by grace c.
quick, good, basic, re order all the time
Posted 2 years ago by Joyce B.
Great pizza... not to mention when I messed up an order, they called to make sure they got me exactly what I wanted and threw in an extra slice for the "inconvenience." Will order again.
Posted 2 years ago by Price P.
Posted 3 years ago by Elizabeth S.
Located right on Grand St, the food is great, the service is amazing, and the price is unbeatable. I have ordered from here several times especially the chicken parm hero (which is my favorite). What's also great is that when I got the spaghetti chicken parm, they separated my pasta and chicken parm. I really appreciate the small things; it goes a long way.
I recommend this place if you're looking for something quick and on a budget. This place will definitely hit the spot.
Posted 3 years ago by Jonathan C.
This place is a bomb. Don't do it.
Posted 3 years ago by jaclyn c.
Good pizza s per usual but the worst wings I have ever tatsted in my life. I want a refund and personal apology from the chef.
Posted 3 years ago by Jacob C.
Fast, close by, super tasty. Everything on the menu is awesome.
Posted 3 years ago by Alexandra S.
HIDEOUS customer service. I ordered the Vodka pizza here multiple times and it tasted really good. Just got a delivery of it and it was so drenched in pepper that my taste buds were burning off. I tried to call and asked it I could reorder it and then said they refused because that's how it's supposed to taste- I beg to differ.
Posted 3 years ago by Amanda J.
Ordered a medium BBQ chicken pizza, manicotti & garlic bread. The pizza was huge which would've been a great thing it it actually tasted good- but it was swimming in oil and it tasted like sweet and sour chicken from the Chinese food store. I would never order pizza from here again. Manicotti lacked flavor and had about a 1 inch layer of melted cheese on top.
Posted 3 years ago by Andre M.
Order from here often. Delivery usually very prompt. Quality usually spot on. The diner special wihch includes side salad, pasta, main corse (I like their Chicken parm - wihch is alway a nice sized portion - always left ofers for lunch the next day) and a can of soda with some italian bread is very good value.
Posted 3 years ago by Eric T.
Fine food, nothing bad, consistently good service.
Posted 3 years ago by Jon B.
The food at Pizza Shack is very good. It is reasonably priced, the people that work there are courteous and delivery is fast!
Posted 3 years ago by John V.
I tried ordering a few weeks ago. They were apparently really busy, so instead of making me wait, they called and gave me the option to cancel my order. I did. To my surprise, they called me like a week later offering their apologies for their business that day and offered me a free mini pizza. The pizza came quickly and tasted great. This place is worth is for the pizza, but it's great because of the service. =)
Posted 3 years ago by Jenna H.
Worst. Hour and a half for a cheese pizza. Nice job. Not even peak hours.
Posted 3 years ago by kevin d.
I love Pizza Shack. I have been eating here for years. The food is delicious and the customer service is excellent!!!
Posted 3 years ago by Clarissa S.
Horrible! After waiting over an hour my "crispy" pizza, it was cold and chewy. Never ordering from here again!!
Posted 3 years ago by Alexis A.
Pizza Shack is a true Italian food gem! The food is top notch and the service is excellent to match. Everything is cooked to order and you definitely can feel the traditional preparation here. They truly shine and are my favorite neighborhood restaurant!
Posted 3 years ago by Kelly P.
I love the ease of going to Seamless.com and ordering from Pizza Shack...always great food...consistent quality....a LES family favorite for myself and my sons for over 20 years.
Posted 3 years ago by cat f.
best pizza in the area
Posted 3 years ago by Adrian S.
pizza shack is so awesome! the delivery always comes quickly and the food is super tasty! everything and more than i'd expect from a cute downtown pizza place @_@
Posted 3 years ago by eric m.
food came 1 hour and 10 minutes after i ordered
i ordered sicilian slice but got regular
got regular coke instead of diet
and the fettuccine alfred is rather bland.
at least the slice was good
Posted 3 years ago by Isaac A.
Can they be less greasy?
Posted 3 years ago by Madeline B.
I literally ate the whole dinner and it was a good size portion of food! It was that good! The meatloaf was seasoned just right and was moist. The mashed potatoes were buttery soft and yummy and don't forget the peas and carrots, prepared perfectly. The tomato relish was the highlight of the dinner. Nice and tangly and had more than enough to put on the meatloaf and mashed potatoes. So good and comforting!
Posted 3 years ago by Chephinia E.
Always fresh!! Just delicious!!
Posted 3 years ago by rose u.
All other venues need to take note: this is how customer service should be done!!!
I asked for a special substitution in the write-in box, and the manager called me with a truly heartfelt apology explaining how the computer didn't allow the override on the dinner special. Sure, I pretty much figured that was the case, but the nice phone call was unexpected. Soon after, the meal arrived, but 2 sodas and a complimentary salad were missing. When I called, the manager seemed legitimately horrified and couldn't stress enough how much he valued my business (it wasn't my first time ordering). The sodas and salad quickly arrived, along with a special gratis entree AND pasta, just as a gesture of good faith! Obviously, since I've ordered from them before, I already thought their food is great -- but now they've locked in a customer for life.
Posted 3 years ago by Evelyn D.
didn't send the salad dressing. garlic bread wasn't toasted. "individual italian cheescake" was a hard hockey puck covered in unidentifiable debris. fork could not penetrate it. too bad... the spaghetti tasted like it was boiled in funky water. the chicken cutlet was surprisingly good. alas, they are closed, so I can't call and complain.
Posted 3 years ago by Beth K.
Good inexpensive pizza! My go to spot...
Posted 3 years ago by Jared J.
If you want no frills, NYC pizza, this is the place. There is a blizzard out there tonight, I tipped generously and I was sent a text message with the status of my order and saying thank you for the generous tip. Even though I was tipping for the weather conditions, it was much appreciated!
Posted 3 years ago by Goldie G.
Huge portions in the Dinner Special. The Chicken Parmigiana was surprisingly flavorful and moist. The spaghetti sauce was a little bland. If I order from here again, I will plan to save half for lunch. Great deal!
Posted 3 years ago by Tim B.
Good food, and some of the best deals in the area. It is HARD to find a 15 dollar large pie these days.
Posted 3 years ago by David M.
1 hour 40 minutes later and still not here. Called twice, first time they told us we didn't order at the time we did and it would be here in a few minutes. Half hour later still waiting. Will never order from here again!!!
Posted 3 years ago by Dayna K.
It's too bad the food is so good because the order was 50 minutes late!
Posted 3 years ago by Dana F.
Lunch special is amazing, Large amount of food for low price, and delicious!
Posted 3 years ago by Robert Z.
Just placed order - ordered a baked ziti, seltzer and a cup of ice. The ziti is ok - not bad but nothing special. no seasoning to it and as a personal preference I would have liked it cooked more. The thing that really bugged me was that they didnt send me the cup of ice that I ordered nor did they notify me that it wasn't coming. I'm 9 months pregnant - can't drink my soda if its not cold and its difficult to get around at this point. If they would've called and told me that they weren't sending it I could have asked someone else going out for lunch to pick it up but everyone has eaten by now. Oh well. Sometimes its the small things that matter most...
Posted 4 years ago by Dina C.
Posted 4 years ago by John E.
From customer service to food taste everything at the pizza shop is worth the price. Rsotto balls are delicious!
Posted 4 years ago by Salam A.
Tired of restaurants quoting dishonest delivery times. 25-40min? More like 1 hr.
Posted 4 years ago by Lee M.
Extremely impressive customer service!
Posted 4 years ago by Julie F.
This is a terrible place to order from and their pizza is a disappointment.
After I made the order, I called them to ask if they could call me on my cell when they arrived at my office and not at my desk phone which I had provided on the order. It took the longest 5 minutes to get the guy to understand this concept.
Then he asked where to deliver it, and I had to explain to him several times to go to the address and floor on the order. Needless to say, that didn't happen, and my colleague who called them asking for a status of the delivery was treated pretty terribly- hung up on twice- before I called them. During their brief conversations, the man on the phone recited the wrong address.
Once the pizza arrived, I was disappointed to see/taste that their pizza's not great. It's more like suburban pizza than NY pizza (we know there's a difference). I never say this, but stay away.
Posted 4 years ago by Melissa P.
The salad was old and wilted and the chicken was swimming in a pool of water. DISGUSTING
Posted 4 years ago by Rani D.
Delivery is always on time and food is hot and fresh. The servers are always willing to get your order right. I order from The Shack frequently
Posted 4 years ago by Jimmy C.
Ordered from them several times during our stay in NY and they only took about half an hour every time (estimated time was 25-50 minutes), the food was yummy and the portions big enough.
Posted 4 years ago by Anika S.
Customer service is second to none. There's better pizza out there but this is nothing to turn your nose up at. Good, solid takeaway place.
Posted 4 years ago by Joe G.
When I got the order confirmation, it gave an Estimated Delivery Time of 30-45 minutes. After 45 minutes I called to inquire on the status, and was told that they were sending it out right then, with Lewis. After another 21 minutes the food finally arrived.
The 18" pizza was decent, but the included packets of toppings were definitely appreciated and they made the slices very tasty. I also ordered 2 orders of garlic knots, and because I have had bad experiences elsewhere (first world problems) getting dry garlic knots I wrote in my order, "Please heat them with olive oil Thank you very much :)" and the garlic knots were TERRIBLE. They were soggy and absolutely inedible to my 2 friends and me; it was a waste of $5.
This was my sole experience with Pizza Shack, but based on it I would not recommend it in good faith, though perhaps they are often much better.
Posted 4 years ago by Jonathan G.
they're the nicest people ever, will text, call you if necessary, offer alternatives and even free stuff. food is good and very cheap so great value.
Posted 4 years ago by omurcan z.
Sweet sauce. Cheap dough. Pizza Mercato is miles ahead. Even Ray's is better, sadly.
Posted 4 years ago by Elizabeth E.
put in an order on seamless, the restaurant didn't have one of the items in stock. so they told me they'd send me a dinner for free. great customer service, and great food.
Posted 4 years ago by Noah K.
I've been living in the L.E.S for about 4 yrs now and I've always ordered from Pizza Shack. My favorite is the chicken parm w penne, chicken marsala, chicken scampi....the list goes on & on. Affordable prices & super fast delivery.
Posted 4 years ago by Melissa L.
Great food and Excellent service. If anything is wrong with the order, just contact the restaurant and they will fix it ASAP. A+
Posted 4 years ago by Evan D.
I've had all kinds of variations on the classic NY pie and enjoyed each one in some way or another. Based on some of the negative reviews for the House Pizza, I specifically requested they make sure the pizza dough was cooked through and the cheese was melted well... When it arrived, I had to put it in the oven. There was barely any sauce and I had to add my own cheese. Still, I only ate half of a piece. This is my first review on any site, that's how strongly I feel. Don't waste your money, this is the worst pizza I've ever encountered.
Posted 4 years ago by Clay M.
The pizza was very oily and over stacked with ingredients. Not a great NYC pizza
Posted 4 years ago by Katy-May H.
Food was great but there is a technical difficulty when ordering. Ordering the chicken paillard ($10.75) under Italian Specialties leads to further erroneous selections which makes you think you get a different meal but it is just the chicken paillard salad ($9.75). I called the manager to make him aware of the issue, $1 difference didn't really matter to me.
Posted 4 years ago by Michael Z.
Good food and the dinner special is the best deal in town!
Posted 4 years ago by jared j.
Very fast delivery, much better than estimated time! The pizza and ravioli arrived hot and good. I will definitely order from here again!
Posted 4 years ago by Amy Z.
Great tasting Italian dinners, pizza always comes hot!
Posted 4 years ago by Danny B.
Food is fantastic. Entree and pasta dishes in particular are delicious but everything on the menu is very good. Service is great. Delivery is quick and food always arrives fresh and hot. Generous potion sizes. A neighborhood gem.
Posted 4 years ago by David B.
The food is amazing! The portions they give you for the price is perfect and even the owner called me checking to see if everything was good! Really backs up their claim of customer satisfaction.
Posted 4 years ago by Justin K.
These guys are always on time... not your typical pizza place food, everything is so great! The salads are generous and fresh!
Posted 4 years ago by Irene C.
pizza was delivered in over an hour and looked like a pie that was sitting and re-heated
pizza was cold and the manager argued with me that it was fresh and did not offer to pick up the pie and re-deliver
Posted 4 years ago by Peter G.
Super friendly. And what a wonderful neighborhood spot. Support local businesses.
Posted 4 years ago by Hyun K.
The food is really great and the customer service was even better. I ordered the wrong thing (IT WAS MY FAULT) so I called over to see if I could get it changed up. I spoke to the owner, Ally, and he took care of it no problem plus some. I was shocked how well they treated my situation and everyone should run their business like them. Top notch, definitely great to see in this town. Really, the food is delicious
Posted 4 years ago by REED W.
Took over an hour, not worth the wait. barley any sauce on my pasta. pizza flavorless and chewy, Does NOT DESERVE 5 STARS on seamless rating. Makes me question credibility with such high accolades for food below par
Posted 4 years ago by Joanna G.
Veggie pizza had a lot more veggies than usual, and they were roasted too (not the usual oven-dried up sad veggies that you often see). I ordered regular dough and it was a bit too doughy/bready for my taste (but they had different dough options and I'll give these a shot next time). Definitely a solid pizza option.
However, I don't really understand the pricing for custom pies. 5-6$ per ingredient?? Does that even make sense? As a vegetarian, if I want to order a different pizza options next time, is it really >30$ for 3 ingredients? If this were clarified I might order from here more often...
Posted 5 years ago by Jordi C.
Don't ever order from here. The pizza is always an hour late and the people who work here are clueless. Save yourself the headache of this dump. HORRIBLE HORRIBLE HORRIBLE
Posted 5 years ago by Emily S.
This place is YUMMY.. the baked ziti is the bomb. The house salad dressing is delicious. Great value and quality ingredients! Im on my 4th night straight of this place! The pizza is good too!
Posted 5 years ago by laura b.
I really love this place! HUGE portions and fast delivery.
Posted 5 years ago by Elizabeth K.
I had the pasta from here a few times and thought it was pretty good, but my latest order will be my last. I ordered the Carbonara and I found a thin piece of metal in my food. It looks like it came from metal being cut (possibly a can being opened). I guess it doesn't matter where it came from but it doesn't belong in my food.
Posted 5 years ago by Ian M.
great food and fast delivery, granted they are two blocks away! the owner is nice and he calls from time to time to check if we liked our order.
Posted 5 years ago by marc c.
Amazing service & food !!!
Posted 5 years ago by Christine N.
always great food, excellent service!! if you are in the mood for great italian food, look no further!
Posted 5 years ago by angelique v.
Great pizza. Base a little too thick (I'll go for "crispy" next time)but just the right amount of cheese. This might just be my new pizza delivery place
Posted 5 years ago by Catherine O.
The house pizza is so delicious and filling. Great pie
Posted 5 years ago by Newman H.
I love the customer service- I don't know how many owners pick up the phone and help you out and accomodate---but pizza shack does! They even send christmas cards to their customers?!
honestly, great sauce. Also, generous portions.
If only more places were like this.
Old school values, with real italian flavors.
Posted 5 years ago by Melissa M.
Had a little mishap with our order- we got the wrong size pie- As soon as we called they were so polite and apologetic and immediately sent over the right size. Plus we got to keep the first one! The service was exceptional and the pie was delicious- will definetly be eating there often in the future!
Posted 5 years ago by kathy r.
Good food and fast delivery...plus they're the nicest people to talk to!
Posted 5 years ago by Drita C.
pizza is up to pa. wings are surprisingly great but only 6 or 7 in an order
Posted 5 years ago by patrick c.
Top notch food... easily matches up against some of the best Italian restaurants in the city. Pasta is great, chicken artichoke excellent, delicious!
Posted 5 years ago by Chi L.
Their food really tastes home cooked! amazing sauce, reasonable portions for their price, i would definitely order again, this is already my fifth time ordering, and they never fail, they really appreciatte their customers, and if there's something you don't agree with they are there to fix it, which it only happened once that something was forgotten.
Posted 5 years ago by thaty b.
Pizza Shack is great :) I love their lasagna (very flavorful and great portions) and their pizza is great - the sauce is delicious (same sauce as their lasagna, I believe). The crust is never hard!
Posted 5 years ago by Janny W.
The lunch and dinner specials are an incredible deal, and the puttanesca sauce is particularly good. Also love the small pizza which is ideally sized. The management also makes a particularly good effort at reaching out to their customers and letting them know they are appreciated - I order more from here than any other restaurant on Seamlessweb.
Posted 5 years ago by Andy C.
I am a native New Yorker, and I know pizza.
Pizza Shack is the best pizza in the area, and perhaps in all of Manhattan.
Don't even bother with the other places -- this is the one.
Posted 5 years ago by Thomas G.
Love this place! Family friendly, great food and fantastic service. From the pastas to their pizza you cant go wrong here
Posted 5 years ago by erin r.
Best Italian food in NYC. Pizza is great, meals are family style, price is very reasonable. Highly recommend Pizza Shack to anyone.
Posted 5 years ago by Steve R.
Nothing special. Your typical NYC pizzeria. While the pizza was the norm, the meatball parm hero actually was above average and I'd order that again.
Posted 5 years ago by jon l.
great local italian!
Posted 5 years ago by Julia G.
I highly recommend the meatballs and pasta dishes at Pizza Shack. Don't let the "Pizza" part of the name fool you. The baked ziti and lasagna are amazing!
Posted 5 years ago by Lori H.
Pizza good, service bad.
Posted 5 years ago by Paloma L.
Delicious Chicken Parm
Posted 5 years ago by Kevin C.
Order took wayyyyyyy too long. When we called to ask how long it would be, the guy said it hadnt left yet, and then when asked how long he said "7"
Posted 5 years ago by Randi R.
Really solid pizza delivery in the area. Consistent and delicious.
Posted 5 years ago by Philip C.
Just got pizza delivered and food from Pizza Shack Mm-mm, yummy, yum, tangy, sweet, saucy, cheesy, crispy and just the right doughy goodness of your Sicilian slice. Love it! I'm a fan of both the middle and end slice. Mmm good on your regular slice too- the right amount of sauce, cheese, spices, size, crust, crispness and density. Dough factor- right on. You beat nearby A-1 Pizza and Two Boots in a heartbeat as far as my palate is concerned. I'm so focused on the pizza, I'm neglecting to mention that Pizza Shack has an expansive menu including pasta dishes, salads, soups, Italian sandwiches too. I had a warm spinach salad with cannelli beans that was fresh and flavorful. Pizza Shack (in a neighborhood that needs more good diverse eateries), at least we Grand Streeters can count on PS for a top-notch service from Pizza Shack!
Posted 5 years ago by Ally D.
Delivery is always very prompt, and the delivery guy is one of the friendliest around. One of the better pizza places in the neighborhood and their baked ziti is really good.
Posted 5 years ago by Tareq M.
Pizza was pretty blah and it took over an hour to get here - we're a few blocks away, Soup was interesting - We'll stick with 2 boots from now on
Posted 5 years ago by Lilly c.
excellent food. the best pizza in the area
Posted 5 years ago by Bobby M.
Pizza Shack's service was the best in the city and the mushroom and garlic pizza was absoluely delicious. I will be ordering from here every time!
Posted 5 years ago by Kimberly B.
Great service. A business run the right way.
Posted 5 years ago by Daniel L.
Great appitzers and garlic bread.Marinara Sauce was a bit weak and watery
Posted 5 years ago by kris s.
I've said it before, I'll say it again, great tasting Italian food (not just pizza), reasonable prices and good people. How could you not love these guys? For example, once they ran out of wings right after my order was completed. The charge already had gone thru on Seamless so the guy called and said, "we just ran out of wings, next time you order put it in the instruction box and we'll send em. So I did just that and they came and I thought that that simple notion says alot about these guys. No trouble or awkwardness, just good solid business. And like I said, their food is delicious.
Posted 5 years ago by Michael P.
They always have great food and do an awesome job to ensure you get what you ordered. This is our go-to pizza place and they have so much more than just pizza. Such great service too!!!
Posted 5 years ago by Amanda S.
It's hard to make a bad pizza, but they managed. Hard and chewy dough, mushy meatball slices. If I were starving I'd eat it, but there are so many great pizza places in NYC. yuk
Posted 5 years ago by Victoria G.
love these guys. good pizza and surprisingly delicious pastas! their delivery times are very reasonable and prices are great (for manhattan). ive had their vodka mini pie (4/5 just wish it was a little bigger for the price), spaghetti with meatballs (4/5), penne with vodka sauce (5/5), calamari (5/5 very crispy, not overcooked and they hook it up with the lemon), garlic bread (5/5 good and garlicky), and chicken francese (5/5 light but flavorful). keep in mind that this is a local pizza joint, so dont go expecting haute cuisine. you get an honest meal sent to your door that is consistently done right - the old school new yawk way.
Posted 5 years ago by sean m.
Amazing pizza and service. The House pizza is by far the best. This is the best pizza i have had in a while in the lower east side. if you want good pizza then call Pizza Shack you will not be dissapointed in anyway. I have had pizza from all over in the lower east side and downtown but this place is great. I just wanted to add on that i have spoken to the owner a few times. He makes sure the food is always its best and will help you out in anyway. I love this pizza and food. It just gets better each time. I recomend asking for the thin crust the pizza is even more perfect.
Posted 5 years ago by Seneca C.
BEST Italian on the Lower East Side, if not the whole city!
Posted 5 years ago by Dominick P.
Ordered pizza delivery. Pizza was excellent, arrived hot and fresh in a reasonable amount of time. The most impressive part though, I got a CALL from the OWNER a couple hours after the pizza was delivered to ask how it was and make sure everything was OK. Pizza Shack is my delivery place, locked in.
Posted 6 years ago by Matthew T.
Great food, large portions and incredible service. The owner called personally to ensure I enjoyed my meal. That's unheard of in New York. A++ Highly Recommended.
Posted 6 years ago by Charlie R.
We ordered from Pizza Shack today and were incredibly dissapointed. We ordered the house special pizza, buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks and garlic bread and we unhappy with everything that was ordered. The pizza was incredibly bland, the base doughy and the topping was excessive but still tasteless. The garlic bread, mozzarrella sticks and chicken wings were also bland.
We would not have commented except for the fact that we only ordered from Pizza Shack based on the rating provided by seamless web. We certainly wont be ordering from Pizza Shack again.
Posted 6 years ago by Narell D.
Prompt delivery, LOVED the baked ziti. Received a handwritten note a few days later from the owner thanking me for my order and hoping I enjoyed it, never had that happen before especially not in NYC, AMAZING.
Posted 6 years ago by elle t.
Love, Love, Love the eggplant parm. all the pastas are delicious and the delivery is super fast & friendly!
Posted 6 years ago by Elisha G.
The wings were pretty good, but not rave worthy. The sandwich was delicious though.
Posted 6 years ago by David B.
This place cares. Usually when SeamlessWeb tells me "This establishment doesn't support eco-friendly ordering," I just copy it and paste it into the comment box. I figure they're probably unaware. Next day, after my order, the owner of Pizza Shack personally calls me to ask about my comment. He really wanted to make sure I loved his pizza and his business. I do! Pizza was great, management is top notch. In a place as busy as New York, you have to respect that level of care.
Posted 6 years ago by Mattew A.
The pizza is great and is made exactly as requested. The owner himself calls you to make sure you are happy with your order. This is rare to begin with but in NYC, this has NEVER happened to me. The delivery is good. We have tried many pizza places in the neighborhood and this one is the best. Enjoy.
Posted 6 years ago by Anthony D.
Terrific pizza, wonderful Italian food and stellar service!
I used to walk the few blocks to Pizza Shack to sit down and eat lunch because I thoroughly enjoyed talking with the people that work there. Everyone is extremely friendly. Recently, an accident rendered me immobile. On top of not being able to walk, I realized I would also miss out the cordial old-world service I got from Pizza Shack. A friend of mine said I could order online and so I have. Not too long after ordering I got a phone call! The owner had recognized my name and called me to see how I was doing. I had ordered their stellar chicken parmigiana - always cooked to PERFECTION with a great sauce made from as close to scratch as you can get without growing the San Marzano tomatoes in the store.
As I convalesce, I have a smile on my face and will shortly have a smiling stomach thanks to the good people at Pizza Shack. They really go the extra mile!
Posted 6 years ago by Morris G.
Had undercooked chicken from here. Will not order again.
Posted 6 years ago by Ryan C.
Great traditional style pizza in the hood. Family still lives in Little Italy!
Posted 6 years ago by Doug E.
every part of this pizza was awesome!
Posted 6 years ago by Irene R.
We love this place! It's been the best Italian delivery we've found! Everything tastes fresh and homemade! We've tried a number of their pasta and chicken dishes and have been happy with every one!
Posted 6 years ago by Meg O.
This restaurant delivers and resolves outstanding issues in a timely manner. The food is quite good, exactly as expected. I recommend this establishment wholeheartedly.
Posted 6 years ago by Mark L.
HORRIBLE. I ordered pizza with meatballs and buffalo chicken wings. The wings were slightly larger than the size of my pinky toe and the buffalo sauce tasted more of cinnamon than hot sauce. I paid for an extra thing of blue cheese dressing and didn't get it. The pizza tasted like nothing. If I liked the taste of nothing I would have eaten the air around me instead of ordering a pizza. Perhaps I'll do that next time.
Posted 6 years ago by Gregg A.
The food took more than an hour to arrive. It was mediocre when it got here and pretty cold too. The pizza was nothing special - there are far too many good pizzerias in NYC for this to compete. Maybe the italian dishes are better?
Posted 6 years ago by Vijay P.
Ziti Siciliano is the best.
Sauteed zucchini is awesome
Posted 6 years ago by Miriam V.
Posted 6 years ago by Eric W.
I have ordered from Pizza Shack twice, once from Seamless and another time directly through the store. I must say that the previous reviews are legit, the owner called me to confirm my order, and then once again to confirm I enjoyed the food. My first delivery was slow, but the second one was super fast.
I love the Penne a la vodka. I had it twice and it did not disappoint. The pizza is pretty good, i like the home made sauce with the basil, garlic and small chunks of tomato. The price is pretty good for the neighborhood.
Posted 6 years ago by Jason E.
Delivery is extremely slow. Usually over 1 hour.
Pastas here are great, they always arrive hot , the price is super-cheap and there is enough for 2 days.
PIZZA IS TERRIBLE. The last time I ordered I had to throw the whole pizza out because it tasted like someone poured sugar on it (maybe too much sugar in the sauce) and it arrived cold. I'll stick with their pastas only from now on.
Posted 7 years ago by Nicole P.
Love the pizza here. The minestrone soup is good too.
Posted 7 years ago by Alexandra G.
Definitely some of the best pizza on the LES. The House Pizza is particularly good. Pretty quick delivery and a great staff--sometimes the owner calls and follows up on your order.
Posted 7 years ago by Andrew H.
The food is always delicious and the owner couldn't be nicer. From the chicken marsala to the pizza its one of the best spots in the area.
Posted 7 years ago by Justin I.
good/friendly service. Owner took the time to call afterwards and see how the meal was.
Posted 7 years ago by Timothy R.
Great food - great chicken parm
there was a miscommunication between seamlessweb and the store, but the store called me personally afterwards to apologize - thats good customer service.
and they make a great chicken parm
Posted 7 years ago by Scott L.
I have been ordering from this place for years - and am happy that they are finally on Seamless Web. My order always gets delivered quickly and correctly! Personally love ordering their mushroom pizza or a pasta dish - my husband loves the chicken roll.
Posted 7 years ago by pauline w.
Three stars for ok pizza, excellent service. First time I have ever been called by the proprietor after the delivery to ensure that it was timely and I was pleased with my order. I was very impressed with the high level of service.
Posted 7 years ago by Matt L.
Fast, hot, and delicious, followed up by a personal phone call from the owner of the restaurant to make sure we were happy. Recommended.
Posted 7 years ago by James P.
I have lived in NYC a few years and must say this is the best pizza I have had delivered, delivery was quick the ingredients were fresh and wonderful. This will now be my "go to" place. To top it all off I got a courtesy call just to make sure everything was as I wanted it. By the way I got the Chicken Marsala Pizza and it was amazing.
Posted 7 years ago by Hunter D.
amazing pizza! get it
Posted 7 years ago by Stephanie W.
Pizza Shack received my order just a couple of minutes after I had placed it, and called me to confirm my special order which was great since the food came perfectly! It was very good, the portions were very generous, and overall a pleasant experience. I will order from again.
Posted 7 years ago by Jon T.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Don Alphonso's Trattoria Pizzeria (Pizza Shack)'s overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from
Don Alphonso's Trattoria Pizzeria (Pizza Shack) by entering your address
below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.